Piano Guidance
Photo by RODNAE Productions Pexels Logo Photo: RODNAE Productions

Which is harder piano or harp?

Is harp more difficult than piano? About the same: harder at first, but easier in the long run. You can sit down at a harp and instantly sound harp-like.

What software does Hans Zimmer use?
What software does Hans Zimmer use?

Steinberg Cubase Hans Zimmer doesn't use one, but two DAWs or “Digital Audio Workstations,” each with its own set of benefits to ensure that he has...

Read More »
What kind of music is for depression?
What kind of music is for depression?

Music Genres and Depression The top genre for depressed listeners is rock, followed closely by alternative, pop, and hip-hop/rap. On the other end...

Read More »

Frequently asked questions

Here are some questions and answers that I’m frequently asked about playing and learning to play the harp.

Is harp more difficult than piano?

About the same: harder at first, but easier in the long run.

You can sit down at a harp and instantly sound harp-like. The sound is welcoming and special. It’s very difficult to make a harp sound bad. The harder part in this comparison is how intuitive the piano-playing motion is versus harp playing. Playing piano keys is like typing or finger painting. If you ask anyone to mime piano playing, they will likely do the correct moves. For harps, not only is the motion of playing the strings un-intuitive, it’s also counter-intuitive: most people think you yank sideways instead of pulling in (fingers) and pushing away (thumb). Both instruments require you to use two hands to play two sets of notes. Usually your right hand is the melody and your left hand the accompaniment. This is a different concept from using one hand to place notes and the other to play them, like in guitar or violin, or both hands to place notes while your breath plays them, like flute or clarinet. Piano uses all 10 fingers, and harp only uses 8. On piano, you have to understand more theory about when to use the black keys than you do on harp, which uses levers or pedals that often don’t change through an entire song. These two aspects make harp easier in the long run.

Do I have to learn piano before I can play harp?

No.

If you’ve played piano before, then you have experience playing notes with both hands and reading the grand staff. That will give you a leg up, but is certainly not required for starting harp.

Will I get calluses?

Not really.

I got some small calluses when I was playing pedal harp, which has strings that are generally more tense to pull on than lever harp strings, causing more abrasion. Those calluses were barely noticeable.

Since playing lever harp, I have not developed any calluses.

Do you have to get someone to tune it?

You tune it yourself.

Strings go out of tune if the temperature changes, when they’re new, when the harp is new, or if the harp is not well made.

You probably won’t have to tune it every time you play.

Do Re Mi notes for Mary had a little lamb?
Do Re Mi notes for Mary had a little lamb?

The solfege syllables for Mary Had A Little Lamb is simple and includes only 4 pitches: do, re, mi, and sol. Here are the phrases broken down: Mi...

Read More »
What song has the hardest guitar riff?
What song has the hardest guitar riff?

Here Are the Hardest Guitar Solos Ever Through the Fire and Flames by DragonForce (Herman Li) ... Dissimulation by Born of Osiris (Jason...

Read More »

How long will it take until I’m any good?

Somewhere between immediately and never.

I can show you in one lesson how to impress your friends—after all, you’ve picked an impressive instrument. But usually when people are looking to be “any good,” they want to be a virtuoso. And sometimes even virtuosos still aren’t “good enough” in their opinion. I will help you pick music that you like and that is easy enough for you to play well. I will help you overcome any stage fright. I will teach you to maximize your practice time. I will give you techniques for working through trouble spots and to improvise through a memory block. Adults usually think they should progress much faster than they will because, as an adult, you feel that you should be able to do things, well, faster. Learning an instrument is a new skill. How long before you were “any good” at penmanship, skiing, or cooking? You didn’t start out perfectly, but you got by, and eventually you became “good enough.”

Do I have to learn theory/read music/memorize songs?

No.

I’m a big fan of knowing why you are learning what your teacher wants to teach you. I do not teach things just because they are in some method, or because my teacher taught me that way. I teach what you need to reach the goals you have. If you don’t have any goals that can be reached by learning theory, or how to read music, or memorizing, then I will not make you learn those. (I do have a list of music theory resources that might show you that it’s not as scary as you think, but I won’t force you to use any of them.)

Find out more about setting your music goals.

Do I have to buy/rent a harp?

You have to be able to practice.

I don’t demand that you practice a lot. Try for 5 minutes a day. If you don’t have a harp available to you, this becomes difficult. The harder it is for you to get to the harp, the less likely it is that you will practice today. Instead, you will put it off until tomorrow. Suddenly tomorrow is the lesson, and you have not practiced. It is easier than you think to rent. Find out more about renting or buying a harp.

What is harder to learn guitar or piano?
What is harder to learn guitar or piano?

Guitar is easier for adults to learn because it is less challenging to learn songs at the beginner level. Piano, however, is easier for younger...

Read More »
Does playing guitar ever stop hurting?
Does playing guitar ever stop hurting?

Fingertip soreness is temporary and can last a week or more. It doesn't require treatment, although icing and numbing creams can provide short-term...

Read More »

Do I have to cut my nails?

Maybe...

The technique that I use and that I know how to teach utilizes the pads of your fingers, which can only be reached if you cut your nails all the way down. If you do not want to cut your nails, you have two choices for learning to play with nails: make it up as we go along, or learn from a teacher who teaches the technique of playing with nails. Nails are used on the Paraguayan harp (right hand), in wire-strung technique, and in some Celtic and Early music technique. If you stick with me, I will do my best to help you maintain a comfortable hand position, but I do not have experience teaching or playing with nails.

Is a double-strung harp like a double-strung guitar?

No.

A double-strung guitar has each string that a normal guitar has, paired with those same notes an octave higher. A double-strung harp has exactly the same strings on both sides. On a double-strung guitar, when you play a “string,” you strike both the regular and higher octave strings at the same time. On a double-strung harp, you use a different hand on each row of strings, and there is no connection between the rows. There is a lovely double-strung technique you can use to echo the same notes on both sides, or a technique to play the same notes in unison, but you don’t have to do this.

Learn more about the double-strung harp.

How do I become a student?

Just contact me.

I only teach adults. I’ll ask you about your goals to make sure we’re a good fit. If you are looking for lessons for children or lessons for yourself to attain a goal I am not familiar with, I have other teachers that I can refer you to.

What are your rates?

See my rates page for lesson prices, what’s included, and how to determine the frequency and duration of lessons. Ready to contact me? If not, get some tips on stretching and practicing. Explore more harp resources.

What are the best key caps to get?
What are the best key caps to get?

20 Best Keycaps: A Complete Buyer's Guide HK Gaming Dye Sublimation Keycaps. New Arrial XDA Lotus Keycaps. YMDK White Gray Black Keycaps. YMDK...

Read More »
What is 2 notes at the same time called?
What is 2 notes at the same time called?

harmony, in music, the sound of two or more notes heard simultaneously.

Read More »
Join almost HALF A MILLION Happy Students Worldwide
Join almost HALF A MILLION Happy Students Worldwide

Pianoforall is one of the most popular online piano courses online and has helped over 450,000 students around the world achieve their dream of playing beautiful piano for over a decade.

Learn More »
How much is a Steinway grand?
How much is a Steinway grand?

between $70,000 and $150,000 The short answer: somewhere between $70,000 and $150,000. For many musicians, a Steinway grand piano is their dream...

Read More »
What kind of paint do you use on a piano?
What kind of paint do you use on a piano?

There are a lot of different paints you can choose for pianos. Many choose chalk paint, as it requires less sanding. I wanted to use a standard...

Read More »