Piano Guidance
Photo by RODNAE Productions Pexels Logo Photo: RODNAE Productions

Can a song have two chord progressions?

While there are maybe two dozen well-known songs that feature just a single chord, there are thousands of two-chord songs. As I mentioned in the one-chord post, one of the most important aspects in music is tension and release, and simply adding a second chord often gives you all the tension and release you need.

Which key is the saddest?
Which key is the saddest?

D minor Historically, classical composers felt that D minor was the most melancholy of the keys, suitable for lamentations, dirges and requiems....

Read More »
Do you need a full size keyboard to learn piano?
Do you need a full size keyboard to learn piano?

The truth is that there is a lot of personal preference. However, there is certainly a minimum viable size for people who want to learn how to play...

Read More »

These songs from decades past show us that you can do a lot with just a little. Let’s explore the magic of the bVII-I progression and how two chords can make a song. In “Sometimes, one chord is all you need,” I discussed how much variety you can squeeze out of just one chord when writing a song. Let’s double the bet and look at some two-chord songs. In the end, we’ll find that, ironically, certain two-chord songs can sound more like a one-chord song than many one-chord songs do. While there are maybe two dozen well-known songs that feature just a single chord, there are thousands of two-chord songs. As I mentioned in the one-chord post, one of the most important aspects in music is tension and release, and simply adding a second chord often gives you all the tension and release you need. (As Lou Reed famously declared: “One chord is fine. Two chords is pushing it. Three chords and you’re into jazz.”)

I-V and I-IV progressions

Most two-chord songs feature a I chord (let’s say C) and either a V or a IV (G and F, respectively). Why? Because the V-I and IV-I cadences are two of the most powerful cadences in music. You find these progressions everywhere in folk, rock, and reggae. Some classic songs in this vein are:

Bruce Springsteen, “Born in the U.S.A.” (B, E)

Hank Williams, “Jambalaya” (C, G)

Traffic / Joe Cocker, “Feeling Alright” (C, F)

The Vaselines / Nirvana “Molly’s Lips” (C, G)

Bob Marley, “Lively Up Yourself,” (D, G)

The specific two-chord progression we’ll explore here, however, is the I-bVII-I (e.g., C-Bb-C). As I mentioned at the top of this article, what I find so interesting about the bVII-I progression is how it works to relentlessly emphasize the I chord, to the point that it obliterates everything around it.

Examples abound

What's the best way to learn piano?
What's the best way to learn piano?

Piano Tips for Beginners Learn the Basics. It may seem obvious but start with the basics. ... Set a Practice Schedule and Stick With It. Practice...

Read More »
What is a good first song to learn on the piano?
What is a good first song to learn on the piano?

Here are seven easy piano songs for beginners to get you started. Twinkle Twinkle. Twinkle Twinkle Little Star is always popular, especially with...

Read More »

A first example, from 1966, is the great “E too D” by the Small Faces, who clearly realized a great progression when they found it. Another song from the mid/late ’60s with the I-bVII-I progression is “Black to Comm” by the MC5. The chords are just E-D-E, although the bVII almost loses its harmonic function, so it feels more like E-and-E-and-E… It’s relentless.

A decade later came “Frankie Teardrop” by Suicide.

To call this a two-chord song is stretching things a bit since I don’t think Martin Rev is actually playing chords as much as two notes, an Eb and an F. But the effect is the same: an endless push to the I, in this case, F. Compare these songs to tracks we featured in the one-chord post, like Aretha’s “Chain of Fools” or Junior Walker’s “Shotgun.” Both of those are true one-chord songs, but they feel more harmonically free. It’s not just a punk thing, either, by the way. Here’s a spacey example: “How Does it Feel?” by Spacemen 3, a band that was heavily influenced by Suicide (they even have a song named “Suicide”) and The MC5 (Spacemen 3’s “Revolution” is essentially a remake of “Black to Comm”).

Similar progressions

It’s interesting how simply changing one thing — the order or emphasis in which you play the chords or changing the tonic to a minor — totally alters the feel of this progression. On the surface, these two songs are very similar to each other. They both use two major chords that are a major second apart (“Fire” goes B-A-B-A and “Jane” goes G-A-G-A), and they both spend equal time on each chord. However, I would argue that simply by beginning on B and going down to A, “Fire” is clearly in B, whereas “Jane,” which moves in the opposite direction (G to A) doesn’t feel like it’s clearly in either G or A. It also doesn’t help that Perry Farrell is singing notes that don’t fit in either chord. (It almost feels like he’s singing in D). Both “Fire” and “Jane” are quite different from our previous examples. Even though “Fire” feels like a I-bVII-I progression, it has a different feel to it than, say, “E too D.” Because equal time is spent on each chord, and because each chord is hit on the downbeat, that flat-seventh chord feels more like a substitute for a dominant V chord. In other words, the progression feels like B-A-B-A, as opposed to B-and-B-and-B.

How do I quit piano?
How do I quit piano?

How Do I Quit Piano? Be honest. ... Thank them for the time they spent working with you. Give them a nice card or recommendation. Do it in person,...

Read More »
Which guitar chords to learn first?
Which guitar chords to learn first?

The first chords to learn on guitar are Em, C, G, and D. Let's get started in “first position” or “open chords.” These chords are played close to...

Read More »

From tonic to minor

Changing the tonic to a minor (i-bVII-i) makes a dramatic difference as well, giving the song a restless, rootless feeling, not unlike “Jane Says.” Check out “Pushin’ Too Hard” by the Seeds (Bm-A).

There’s also “Break On Through” by the Doors (Em-D)

With both songs, it’s unclear which chord is our tonic, which is exhilarating and perfectly complements the theme of the lyrics. I’ll leave you with probably my favorite song ever, which also happens to be a two-chord song (although I like to think of it as a song with one-and-a-half chords since the bass stays the same). Give it up for the Beatles. Scott McCormick is the author the Audible bestselling Rivals! series and the hit fantasy novel The Dragon Squisher. Scott can be reached at [email protected].

Alternate guitar tuning can inspire your songwriting

Using suspended chords in your songs

How Nashville tuning can transform your arrangements

Eleventh and thirteenth chords: How to play them on guitar

Using augmented chords in your songs

How do pirates say no?
How do pirates say no?

Avast! – Avast was a command that meant to stop or desist, and is derived from the Italian word “basta” which means stop. Aye (or ay) – Aye was the...

Read More »
What is the oldest language on earth?
What is the oldest language on earth?

By order of appearance, Tamil would be considered the world's oldest language as it is over 5,000 years old, having made its first appearance in...

Read More »
Is 49 keys enough for a beginner?
Is 49 keys enough for a beginner?

That's right: 49 keys are enough to get started. Because your instrument is really made up of repeating sets of 12 notes, as long as you have a few...

Read More »
Where the Southern crosses the Yellow Dog meaning?
Where the Southern crosses the Yellow Dog meaning?

Quick explanation, the “Southern” was the east-west rail line that crossed the “Yazoo-Delta” rail line at Moorhead. Yazoo-Delta picked up the name...

Read More »