Piano Guidance
Photo by Nuzhet Flores Pexels Logo Photo: Nuzhet Flores

Are people naturally good at music?

Some people are born with greater aptitude, and they develop skill on a musical instrument much faster than do others and rise to higher stages of advancement. Studies have been conducted on both musical ability and musical inability, revealing strong genetic components to each.

Why do kids quit piano?
Why do kids quit piano?

They Weren't Interested to Begin With. Some students resist piano lessons before they even begin. They have pre-conceived, negative notions of what...

Read More »
What is the world's cheapest instrument?
What is the world's cheapest instrument?

Top 5 Cheap Music Instruments Melodica. Ukulele. Recorder. Tin Whistle. Kalimba. Jul 14, 2022

Read More »

Is Musical Talent Hereditary?

Question: If the piano was invented in 1700 by Bartolomeo Cristofori how can people be born with the ability to play the piano without a lesson, or a savant’s ability to play difficult numbers? – Neil (Kingman, Arizona, USA) Albert’s reply: Talent is primarily about potential rather than the innate ability to perform any given skill, no matter how natural that skill may seem to be. Some people are naturally faster, stronger or smarter than others, and these people naturally navigate to athletics or academics. Similarly, for the very reason you cite nobody is born with the ability to play the piano, but people are born with varying degrees of musical sensitivity and proclivity. Musical talent is a matter of aptitude, not instinct. Some people are born with greater aptitude, and they develop skill on a musical instrument much faster than do others and rise to higher stages of advancement. Studies have been conducted on both musical ability and musical inability, revealing strong genetic components to each. A 2008 study discovered that musical talent is roughly 50 percent genetic, while another, published in 2001, revealed that about 80 percent of tone deafness appears to be genetic.

Is Perfect Pitch Genetic?

Even perfect pitch – the ability to name exact pitches upon hearing them – is a learned skill, albeit it one that most musicians never learn. The international standard of A440 (the A above middle C being tuned to a frequency 440 Hertz) cannot possibly be inborn – after all, this has only been a guideline for the past century or so, and it is by no means adhered to universally at that. In other words, the note we call A is purely arbitrary in terms of frequency and has varied very widely in different places over the centuries. Perfect pitch therefore develops – in those who have the genes or aptitude for it – simply as a memory of pitch. Researchers at the University of California School of Medicine have discovered, for instance, that many people with perfect pitch (more technically called absolute pitch) can name white piano keys more easily than black keys, most certainly due to the bias towards white keys (with their simpler key signatures) in the early stages of musical training. They have also concluded, in controlled heritability studies, that absolute pitch acquisition is strongly genetic. (See the University of California Genetics of Absolute Pitch Study for details.)

Talent Needs Models

How long should you be in the shower to save money?
How long should you be in the shower to save money?

While there is no magic amount of time to spend in the shower to help the planet, shaving just three minutes off an eight-minute shower time can...

Read More »
Do you need a specific gas cap?
Do you need a specific gas cap?

Are fuel caps universal? Most fuel caps are universal and can fit in any car or SUV. But there might be exceptions. Typically, fuel caps have a...

Read More »
Join almost HALF A MILLION Happy Students Worldwide
Join almost HALF A MILLION Happy Students Worldwide

Pianoforall is one of the most popular online piano courses online and has helped over 450,000 students around the world achieve their dream of playing beautiful piano for over a decade.

Learn More »

I think the development – and even discovery – of talent has much to do with models, which is to say goals. Without a model of what’s possible, a person will rarely, if ever, develop a clear goal towards which to strive. I believe that this is one of the areas in which music education needs improvement. While classical radio stations continue to disappear from the airwaves, the internet gives us all on-demand access to a wealth of classical music. The only problem is that we have to search for it – and how many children do so? Young people need classical music in their environment in order to awaken their love, appreciation and talent for music.

A Personal Story

Speaking personally, I think the lack of models is what led to my initial failure at the piano. A certain talent had been discovered when I was in kindergarten. The school principal would play something on the piano and I’d play it back, even though our family had never owned a piano. I assume I must have tinkered around with the piano in the classroom and maybe was starting to develop a sense of pitch, or maybe I just watched which keys he played and quickly reproduced them. (I have no memory of exactly how these tests were performed and doubt that I ever played anything back blindly.) After a couple failed attempts at piano lessons as we moved from one town to another, my childhood teacher fired me, literally telling my mother, “Take your money every week and throw it in the garbage. Albert will never be able to play the piano.” I was nine at the time, and my entire childhood would pass before I ever touched a piano again. Back then, growing up in the remote Pennsylvania suburbs, I never heard classical music beyond the occasional television commercial or Bugs Bunny caricature of the concert pianist. I had no idea that classical music was even still played or that anybody ever listened to it. It just wasn’t part of my reality. In fact – and I am ashamed to admit this – when I was sixteen and my high school literature teacher told me he listened to classical music, I literally laughed in his face. It was the next year that I discovered both my musical talent and classical music. I was very lucky that my piano technique was largely inborn. I immediately had very fast fingers and willed myself to play Chopin and Liszt etudes within months of starting the piano. I obviously wasn’t born playing this music, but I did have the essential finger dexterity built-in. I assume I inherited that dexterity from my mother, who is the fastest and most accurate typist I know, although this is mere speculation.

What is the most difficult wood to carve?
What is the most difficult wood to carve?

Top 10 Hardest Woods in The World Australian Buloke – 5,060 IBF. ... Schinopsis brasiliensis – 4,800 IBF. ... Schinopsis balansae – 4,570 IBF. ......

Read More »
Can I learn piano at 45?
Can I learn piano at 45?

Learning to play the piano as an adult can be intimidating. Many people limit themselves because they think they are too old or that it's too late...

Read More »

Everything else I had to learn. I think if I had a student like me at seventeen or eighteen, I might fire him too. I couldn’t read music, I knew nothing of harmony or counterpoint or phrasing or interpretation, I had no rhythmic control, I had no idea how to practice or how to learn music. I had a decent ear but no real ear training. For that matter, I didn’t have a proper technique to speak of; I just got myself to play technically hard music, but I had no idea how to play it musically or expressively. I was exceedingly fortunate to have found a series of top piano teachers, who gradually imparted the skills and knowledge needed to be a professional musician. More than sheer talent or aptitude, it is training and careful, hard work that ultimately lead to musical success.

How does schizophrenia start out?
How does schizophrenia start out?

The exact causes of schizophrenia are unknown. Research suggests a combination of physical, genetic, psychological and environmental factors can...

Read More »
How long was Vicky and Katrina together?
How long was Vicky and Katrina together?

The couple is said to have been dating since 2019. Last year, India Today questioned Vicky about rumours of him dating Katrina Kaif. In 2020, Vicky...

Read More »
Can you cut a key that has snapped?
Can you cut a key that has snapped?

Can you cut a key from a broken key? It is possible, as long as the parts are available and parts of the key are too damaged, the locksmith will...

Read More »
What celebrity has the most biological kids?
What celebrity has the most biological kids?

Undoubtedly, Nick Cannon seems to be the celebrity with the most biological kids. On October 26th, 2022, Alyssa Scott, Cannon's former flame,...

Read More »